Beware of these “hidden” liabilities when conducting background checks.

Loyal readers may be wondering if this is yet another Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) article. Well, ok, yes. But we’ll also be discussing U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) guidance, as well as liabilities “hiding” in a background check.

What you don’t know can hurt you. So, let’s dive in.

Common Misconceptions

Many employers believe they can simply not hire an applicant—or that they can take negative action against a current employee—based on the results of an employment-related background check report (i.e., consumer report). 

It’s not that simple.

If an employer bases their decision to take adverse action in whole or in part due to the results of a consumer report, they must follow the pre-adverse and adverse action procedures outlined in the FCRA. This includes providing the following to the consumer (applicant/employee) before taking any adverse action:

  • A notice about the intent to take adverse action
  • A copy of the report 
  • Contact information for the consumer reporting agency (CRA) that compiled the report
  • A notice that the CRA did not make the decision to take adverse action and that the consumer can dispute the accuracy or completeness of a report with the CRA
  • The FCRA document, “A Summary of Your Rights Under the Fair Credit Reporting Act”

After notifying the consumer, the employer must wait a reasonable period of time to allow the consumer to dispute the accuracy of the report, typically a minimum of one week. If the consumer does not dispute the report, the employer needs to follow the adverse action process, which includes providing notice of the action, the CRA’s contact information, a copy of the report, and the FCRA summary of rights document.

State laws may require additional steps.

Once those steps are followed, the employer can take adverse action based on any negative findings in the consumer report, right? Not really. Here’s where the EEOC comes in.

Information that Can and Can’t Be Used

The EEOC limits what information from a background check can be used if an employer wants to take any adverse action. Specifically, the information must be job-related and consistent with business necessity. For example, a misdemeanor bad check conviction may not be related to that person’s ability to drive a bus.

EEOC enforcement guidance says an employer or potential employer must “inform the individual that he may be excluded because of past criminal conduct; provide an opportunity to the individual to demonstrate that the exclusion does not properly apply to him; and consider whether the individual’s additional information shows that the policy as applied is not job-related and consistent with business necessity.” The guidance lists examples of other individualized evidence, including:

  • The facts or circumstances surrounding the offense or conduct
  • The number of offenses for which the individual was convicted
  • Older age at the time of conviction, or release from prison
  • Evidence that the individual performed the same type of work, post-conviction, with the same or a different employer, with no known incidents of criminal conduct
  • The length and consistency of employment history before and after the offense or conduct
  • Rehabilitation efforts, e.g., education/training
  • Employment or character references and any other information regarding fitness for the particular position
  • Whether the individual is bonded under a federal, state, or local bonding program

Specific jurisdictions may also mandate these types of assessments. For example, New York City’s Fair Chance Act requires an individualized assessment about criminal records. The assessment is similar to the EEOC’s guidance and, as stated in the enforcement guidance provided by the NYC Commission on Human Rights, requires that employers:

  1. Disclose to the applicant a written copy of any inquiry conducted into the applicant’s criminal history
  2. Share with the applicant a written copy of its Fair Chance Analysis
  3. Allow the applicant at least five business days from receipt of the inquiry and analysis to respond to the employer’s concerns

There are other EEOC issues, such as disparate treatment and/or impact against protected classes, but that’s beyond the scope of this blog. As always, this blog is not meant to be legal advice, and this is a complex issue. With all employment-related legal matters, we recommend consulting with an attorney to ensure compliance and to avoid potentially costly sanctions and/or litigation.

Written by:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Our Reviews

Richard Abrams
Richard Abrams
23:11 14 Sep 22
I was so impressed with the service and work I got from integras.It was a personal issue handled professionally and discreetly. And I love the podcasts!
adrian rosario
adrian rosario
15:51 17 Jul 22
Professional, honest and effective; I have had the privilege of working with Forhad and the Integras executive team since 2007. Having 35+ years experience in law enforcement and an investigative background, we have worked together to achieve successful outcomes investigative matters both domestically and internationally . Their staff is versatile, provides a broad range of security related and investigative know how, and consistently maintains a client-centric culture with unwavering communication and discretion. I highly recommend Integras for your investigative needs.
Brayant Sierra
Brayant Sierra
16:05 08 Apr 22
Elisa Sheftic, Right Executive Search, LLC
Elisa Sheftic, Right Executive Search, LLC
19:50 23 Mar 22
As an executive search firm, having a vendor that is able to execute a background check search, quickly and efficiently is paramount. Integras has been an exceptional partner and understand and communicate the ever changing laws that relate to each state. I would highly recommend them for any companies or recruiting firms that needs a professional background check service. Have used them for years and will continue to do so!
Yftah Kaluski
Yftah Kaluski
18:36 23 Mar 22
Great service and great team behind the product!
Jay McKillop
Jay McKillop
22:58 11 Mar 22
This is a first rate operation, and many of the people that work there are former colleagues. I have dealt with Forhad professionally for over twenty years and he has never let me down. The firm I was at used his team for a "red team" exercise which went extremely well. I have also had several instances where people have come to me with some very complicated investigative problems. I referred them to Intergras and they were extremely pleased with the results. Integras has a very deep bench, with international connectivity and the capacity to get things done.
Gonzalo S.
Gonzalo S.
14:59 26 Jan 22
Sets a standard of excellence in all areas of service it provides. The podcasts provide a wealth of information delivered by a panel professionals with extensive backgrounds. I know the podcast host to be a man of integrity. This has to be the best in the business. Great job!
Joel George
Joel George
22:42 25 Jan 22
We have partnered with Integras Intelligence on a number of occasions. I find their team to be knowledgeable, communicative and easy to work with. It is clear that they are focused on their clients and want to deliver world-class service with an impeccable attention to detail.
Jim Denlea
Jim Denlea
16:05 25 Jan 22
We have used Integras exclusively for all of our Investigative needs, both domestically and internationally. They have always exhibited an unparalleled level of expertise, sensitivity to our client's needs, and cost efficiency. We would highly recommend them without hesitation.
Edmund Hartnett
Edmund Hartnett
15:38 25 Jan 22
Integras Intelligence is the gold standard of investigations. Their cost effective investigations are conducted quickly and accurately; the two most important factors for most clients. I’ve often referred friends and colleagues to Integras. Without exception, they gave the service they received very high marks. I highly recommend Integras.
Aman Singh
Aman Singh
23:31 24 Jan 22
I have had the privilege of working with Integras Intelligence while being at two different companies. Not only is Forhad best in the industry but his team is superb.If you are seeking a company that is professional, responsive and provides thought leadership you should choose Integras Intelligence.Thank You!
Shawn Hale
Shawn Hale
22:06 24 Jan 22
I have known the Integras Intelligence leadership team for over 20 years and am a better person and professional because of it. Never cutting corners, always taking the high road, continually seeking to stay ahead of the industry and setting the standards by which others can measure. Great team. Highly recommend!
Christine Ippolito
Christine Ippolito
00:39 21 Jan 22
We have used Integras as our strategic partner for background checks and physical security advice for over 5 years. The Integras team is highly responsive knowledgeable and always willing to help. We highly recommend them to others and our clients.
Brandon Hunt
Brandon Hunt
13:52 20 Jan 22
I have worked with the team at Integras for over five years and have continually impressed with the professional and thoughtful approach they take to everything they do. They've assembled a terrific team of experts that you can feel confident in and enjoy working with. I strongly recommend Integras Intelligence for anyone who is in need of their services.
Patrick Kane
Patrick Kane
21:51 19 Jan 22
Integras Intelligence is a global leader in the investigative, business intelligence and security consulting space. Their team led by Forhad Razzaque, has a deep level of experience gained in both the public and private sectors.They augment this impressive team with an extensive network of investigators and other specialists that are dedicated to positive client outcomes. If you are looking for a professional, responsive, and skilled partner to help tackle a thorny issue, look no further than Integras.
USMC 0311
USMC 0311
19:36 19 Jan 22
Integras is a leading international provider of investigative and screening services that has been such a great support for our operations in Latin America. Integras is staffed by seasoned professionals who bring decades of experience in all investigative areas and who always go above and beyond the expected service.. Thank you to the Integras team for always striving for excellence!
See All Reviews
js_loader